Predestination is misunderstood...

your interpretation is based on desire being free in an unsaved person.

Is desire still free in a saved person.

Love how you keeping moving the goalposts. First, you started out mocking free will. Then you tried to obfuscate things by bringing "free nature" into the discussion. Now it's free desire.

A heart polluted by sin cannot have any good desires therein. Have you never read:

Eccl 9:3
3 This is the evil in everything that happens under the sun: The same destiny overtakes all. The hearts of men, moreover, are full of evil and there is madness in their hearts while they live, and afterward they join the dead?
NIV

The human heart is literally a cesspool of sin. But even so...the sinners here on earth dearly love their sinful styles, freely choosing to please themselves, which is why they cannot come to the Light they hate so with a passion (Jn 3:20).

I ain't moving no goal posts. The goal posts are not even there,

As your rationalising something that doesn't even exist for a saved person.

God has given you a spirit of discipline

Can you see what ever will you had before you where saved is now God's Will.

I have been talking about unregenerate mankind. You BEGAN by asking me define "free will", which then you morphed into something you called "free nature" and then "free desire".

And, no, God does not obliterate our volition. We Christians still retain all our faculties: Mind, Will, Emotions and Conscience. We're still made in God's image and likeness. The only difference now is that God has empowered us to do battle with and to substantially and essentially, but never perfectly in this life, overcome the "flesh", i.e. our sin nature, which is something else God has not obliterated but will be when our bodies are redeemed on the Last Day. He does this with his gracious New Covenant gifts -- the Holy Spirit and a new heart -- the heart being the seat of the aforementioned faculties. In short, our new heart with its new, godly desires moves us to make us willing to do God's will.

ok So on that note, are are you going to say voluntary choices are the same as your nature.

View attachment 261250

Human nature is created in the image and likeness of God, therefore what's the problem with choices made according to one's nature?

Personally I would say God makes choices based on His character rather than saying His nature but as His character is inherent, unlike us, it is difficult to divide the two in Him.

where does it say in the bible you have free will

Can you see what ever will you had before you where saved is now God's Will.

This is more your opinion than anything else, based on your ability to not accept correction.

Then your trying to fit scripture in with your natural understanding




According to scripture people are changed into the likeness of Christ,

For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he should instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.

Would you say having the mind of Christ is still having your own will 🤔

This is more your opinion than anything else, based on your ability to not accept correction.

Then your trying to fit scripture in with your natural understanding




According to scripture people are changed into the likeness of Christ,

For who hath known the mind of the Lord, that he should instruct him? But we have the mind of Christ.

Would you say having the mind of Christ is still having your own will 🤔

That’s simply wrong. God’s will doesn't supplant the human will when the person is saved. Rather, the Holy Spirit indwells the person and makes it possible for the person to obey God’s will while also making God’s will known to the person. The person is still free and able to do otherwise.

Here's what I would say to you: BYE, BYE. Hope you wake up some day.

That’s simply wrong. God’s will doesn't supplant the human will when the person is saved. Rather, the Holy Spirit indwells the person and makes it possible for the person to obey God’s will while also making God’s will known to the person. The person is still free and able to do otherwise.

Evidently, Mr. Thunder has never read Romans 7 wherein Paul describes his battle with the flesh, most likely as a young believer. In that passage, Paul often spoke of his will.

obviously patience is a virtue, doesn't exist on your will 😊

this depends at what stage your at in being saved, if your at full pint glass stage then you have a new mind and a new heart. Your path is now set,.your will has been broken

And you have fully surrenderd your will 😋

Wrong. The Holy Spirit indwells the believer FULLY at the time of salvation. Salvation is a point-in-time event, and though there is a process around it, the ‘new mind, new heart’ begins immediately.

By the way, the human will is not “broken” but rather surrendered and transformed.

explain at what point salvation comes.

Does it come at first belief

Not at all. Just taking the wise advice of Solomon (Prov 26:4).