Did the Church institute Dec 25th to replace Pagan Festivals with a Christian Theme?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Lisamn

Active member
Dec 29, 2020
795
229
43
It's over. Next year we can take it up again. LOL Time for "Who was St. Valentine and Should I Care" Thread.
Haha..when would be the best time to take it up again next year? When your getting out your tree and ornaments? ;)
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
Matthew and Luke 2 has nothing to do with the christmas celebrations and the apostles and earliest Christians never celebrated the same.It is also now common knowledge that Christ was not born at this time.It is presumptuous to seek to honour God in a way he,not only,did not request but also detests.Your statement about, "every Protestant and reformer celebrated the birth of Christ", is patently false based on the information presented in the post you are responding to..
we are to honor God in all we do. And the context of chapters 2 of Luke and Matthew was his birth and gift were brought to Jesus . The word "Christmas" is not in the Bible as Trinity is not but the advent season is an orthodox expression of faith of the church throughout History of the Church. I stand by the preaching, honoring , and celebrating of the birth of Christ because IT is in the very word of God. you are wrong and clearly ill-equipped of Church historical context of the Birth of Christ.
 
Nov 15, 2020
1,897
362
83
Newcastle, NSW, Australia
we are to honor God in all we do. And the context of chapters 2 of Luke and Matthew was his birth and gift were brought to Jesus . The word "Christmas" is not in the Bible as Trinity is not but the advent season is an orthodox expression of faith of the church throughout History of the Church. I stand by the preaching, honoring , and celebrating of the birth of Christ because IT is in the very word of God. you are wrong and clearly ill-equipped of Church historical context of the Birth of Christ.
have you read the pdf ?
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
have you read the pdf ?
yes I did and I found it to be very much as I thought it was. the PDF said something that was simple not true.

The day and the time of His birth had no relevance to them, because Jesus was no longer physically on earth. He had returned to heaven. And it was the risen, exalted Christ to whom they looked, and that by faith -- not a babe laid in a manger. Jesus Christ is no longer a baby; no longer the "Christ-child," but the exalted Lord of all.

The old Testament Prophet spoke of a' Virgin shall conceive". God himself spoke of the seed of women in Genesis. The Gospel account testify of over three just about HIS Birth. prophecy of HIS Birth , birth place, and signs in the heavens .

what happen that was very much different about this child being born if was no big deal and waste time to recorded the event in the word of God. what happen ? we hear Angels seek men and tell them who was born and where, they were told to go and worship HIM a baby at the time.

The idea that the virgin Mary is in anyway associated with the pagan when this guy says

were still able to worship their old gods, but merely under different names. It mattered not to themwhether they worshiped the Egyptian goddess mother and her child under the old names (Isis and Horus), or under the names of the "Virgin Mary" and the "Christ-child." Either way, it was the same old idol-religion

You have an issue with the RCC take up with them. BUT for your information Mary was the name of the Mother of Jesus who was a virgin when she gave birth which was an old Testament fulfillment. The term " Christ- Child" in contextually correct as we see in Matthew 1:18 and 2tim3:15. They are not the something as an Egyptian goddesss. Only a fool would draw that collusion in light of the word of God.

NO Just say thesis about an attack on the RCC who did have pagan practices. BUT what the church has done in honoring and worshiping the Lord Jesus birth is edifying. BUT you and those like want to drag the devil in everything. Her name was Mary, she was a virgin as the word of God says most people do not think Pagan goddesses at Christmas they think of Jesus birth as my grandparents, and parents and my children have come to k now over the past 10 generation. just a bunch of devil seeking everywhere in everything because RCC had something to do with it historically. wrong!
 
Nov 15, 2020
1,897
362
83
Newcastle, NSW, Australia
yes I did and I found it to be very much as I thought it was. the PDF said something that was simple not true.

The day and the time of His birth had no relevance to them, because Jesus was no longer physically on earth. He had returned to heaven. And it was the risen, exalted Christ to whom they looked, and that by faith -- not a babe laid in a manger. Jesus Christ is no longer a baby; no longer the "Christ-child," but the exalted Lord of all.

The old Testament Prophet spoke of a' Virgin shall conceive". God himself spoke of the seed of women in Genesis. The Gospel account testify of over three just about HIS Birth. prophecy of HIS Birth , birth place, and signs in the heavens .

what happen that was very much different about this child being born if was no big deal and waste time to recorded the event in the word of God. what happen ? we hear Angels seek men and tell them who was born and where, they were told to go and worship HIM a baby at the time.

The idea that the virgin Mary is in anyway associated with the pagan when this guy says

were still able to worship their old gods, but merely under different names. It mattered not to themwhether they worshiped the Egyptian goddess mother and her child under the old names (Isis and Horus), or under the names of the "Virgin Mary" and the "Christ-child." Either way, it was the same old idol-religion

You have an issue with the RCC take up with them. BUT for your information Mary was the name of the Mother of Jesus who was a virgin when she gave birth which was an old Testament fulfillment. The term " Christ- Child" in contextually correct as we see in Matthew 1:18 and 2tim3:15. They are not the something as an Egyptian goddesss. Only a fool would draw that collusion in light of the word of God.

NO Just say thesis about an attack on the RCC who did have pagan practices. BUT what the church has done in honoring and worshiping the Lord Jesus birth is edifying. BUT you and those like want to drag the devil in everything. Her name was Mary, she was a virgin as the word of God says most people do not think Pagan goddesses at Christmas they think of Jesus birth as my grandparents, and parents and my children have come to k now over the past 10 generation. just a bunch of devil seeking everywhere in everything because RCC had something to do with it historically. wrong!
so, Xmas is the birth of Jesus ? 😆😆😆😆😆😆
Ok, well, thats your choice to believe that.
Looks like we will have to agree to disagree. 😀
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
so, Xmas is the birth of Jesus ? 😆😆😆😆😆😆
Ok, well, thats your choice to believe that.

Looks like we will have to agree to disagree. 😀
no, as I said before "XMAS" is the removal of Christ in Christmas. The Advent season, which is the time to reflect and set apart time to commemorate the birth of Jesus, one of the holiest times in the Christian faith. The only time I have heard of "XMAS" was by atheists and non-Christians and those who had to interject a false narrative about Christmas. The Church Historically has set apart times and seasons known as the Advent and that calendar starts with many holy ( set apart) events which all are documented in the word od God.

not from Egypt, not from pagan, but from the Biblical accounts recorded in the Word of God here they are you can tell me which event did not happen in the Bible and use a pagan explanation for what the Bible says :

  1. Christmas = the birth of Christ
  2. The Baptism of the Lord
  3. The transfiguration a
  4. Palm Sunday Jesus's triumphant entry start of holy week
  5. Easter the death Burial and resurrection
  6. the Ascension
  7. Pentecost
IF you want to find pagan rituals and practices in the word of God and associate them with the Birth of Christ please be my guest, however, your argument in wanting to attack the RCC has run over to those who are not even RCC or practice or hold to or taught about the solise pagan beliefs.

There is bad history of the early Church but the birth of Christ and the Advent season is praise-worthy and edifying. Insulting the Mother of Jesus and trying to draw a narrative of an Egyptian goddess which are false and unreal with an actual person a woman who was named Mary a virgin who conceived by the Holy Spirit which the Word of God says ALL men will call you blessed. I will not insult the Lord's Momma. YOu can if you like. BUT don't lie about the association of false goddesses and mary a real person documented in the Biblical account and genealogy of Jesus.
 

Lisamn

Active member
Dec 29, 2020
795
229
43
IF you want to find pagan rituals and practices in the word of God and associate them with the Birth of Christ please be my guest, however, your argument in wanting to attack the RCC has run over to those who are not even RCC or practice or hold to or taught about the solise pagan beliefs.

There is bad history of the early Church but the birth of Christ and the Advent season is praise-worthy and edifying. Insulting the Mother of Jesus and trying to draw a narrative of an Egyptian goddess which are false and unreal with an actual person a woman who was named Mary a virgin who conceived by the Holy Spirit which the Word of God says ALL men will call you blessed. I will not insult the Lord's Momma. YOu can if you like. BUT don't lie about the association of false goddesses and mary a real person documented in the Biblical account and genealogy of Jesus.
Isn’t that what the RCC did though..they let other religions keep some of their practices as long as they incorporated the RCC’s teachings to? I have read that the 25th of December was a pagan holiday and Christians tried to make a Christian holiday. However..wouldn’t it make more sense that the RCC was just doing what they do? They added the pagan holiday to their teachings to incorporate the pagans into their religion? Catholic does mean universal.

I thought that many religions have the mother/child. While trying to remember Semiramis’ name I came across this article that lays out what I’m trying to talk about.

https://www.bibletools.org/index.cf...show/RTD/cgg/ID/3048/Mother-Child-Worship.htm

Though I do know that Mary was Jesus’ mom..we shouldn’t worship her..she’s human. Yet..satan made sure that many times in history mother/child worship was a thing and the catholics continue the tradition.
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
Isn’t that what the RCC did though..they let other religions keep some of their practices as long as they incorporated the RCC’s teachings to? I have read that the 25th of December was a pagan holiday and Christians tried to make a Christian holiday. However..wouldn’t it make more sense that the RCC was just doing what they do? They added the pagan holiday to their teachings to incorporate the pagans into their religion? Catholic does mean universal.

I thought that many religions have the mother/child. While trying to remember Semiramis’ name I came across this article that lays out what I’m trying to talk about.

https://www.bibletools.org/index.cf...show/RTD/cgg/ID/3048/Mother-Child-Worship.htm

Though I do know that Mary was Jesus’ mom..we shouldn’t worship her..she’s human. Yet..satan made sure that many times in history mother/child worship was a thing and the catholics continue the tradition.
the RCC worships her but we a don't throw out the word of God because of RCC error. The word of God says Mary shall be called Blessed not the RCC. Then address the RCC error don't try to make all who are Christians practicing pagan beliefs by default. Don't assume all practice pagan worship just because one says merry Christmas. Do you watch the Super Bowl or have you ever? You have engaged in more perversion and attack on Gods plan for family in one commercial, BUT saying "merry Christmas" Oh my the flames of hell!
 

Lisamn

Active member
Dec 29, 2020
795
229
43
the RCC worships her but we a don't throw out the word of God because of RCC error. The word of God says Mary shall be called Blessed not the RCC. Then address the RCC error don't try to make all who are Christians practicing pagan beliefs by default. Don't assume all practice pagan worship just because one says merry Christmas. Do you watch the Super Bowl or have you ever? You have engaged in more perversion and attack on Gods plan for family in one commercial, BUT saying "merry Christmas" Oh my the flames of hell!
I think one should think about what they do and if they are doing wrong...turn away from it. Just because it is a tradition that you may have liked all your life..doesn’t mean that its a good thing to continue to do when you learn the truth of it. After all we do worship in sprit and truth. God teaches us things every day. If you learn that what you celebrate is wrong...then you should stop it and turn away from it.

I don’t believe the Super Bowl has ever been attached in anyway to the gospel..so you’re arguing apples and oranges now. But saying merry christmas when its actually merry christ mass is wrong.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,424
6,703
113
There is only One Intermediary between man and the Father, Jesus-Yeshua, Who, by the way, is God.

If Mary were to come back to hear people actually praying to her, and asking her to pray for them, I am certain, for she was the picture of humility, she would be very embarrassed. She is the mother of our Savior, sure, but pray to her? Bid her pray for us? That is a very wrong manner of honoring her.

Mary is blessed among all womankind, and only to be revered as so, nothing more.

I praise God for her, Joseph and all the holy people, fellows in our Savior, amen.
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
I think one should think about what they do and if they are doing wrong...turn away from it. Just because it is a tradition that you may have liked all your life..doesn’t mean that its a good thing to continue to do when you learn the truth of it. After all we do worship in sprit and truth. God teaches us things every day. If you learn that what you celebrate is wrong...then you should stop it and turn away from it.

I don’t believe the Super Bowl has ever been attached in anyway to the gospel..so you’re arguing apples and oranges now. But saying merry christmas when its actually merry christ mass is wrong.
again that is what you think but you have not proven your point of pagan worship by default. make sure you turn away from the Super Bowl, world series, Netflix etc.. The context of Christmas is not pagan in the Christian world view it is the birth of Christ. Found in the New Testament known as the word of God. Jesus never said don't honor his birth the decibels never said don't honor his birth. Old Testament Prophecy was fulfilled at HIS Birth. the Promise of the Lord coming was foretold BY God the Father Angel worshiped kings worshiped Shepard's worshiped prophets prophesied the Holy Spirit moved signs in heaven were given. ALL that is in the very word of God if you have found a pagan , Egyptian goddess being worshiped out of all that YOU NEED to start LOOKING AT the BIBLE.


Whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report ... think on these things." Philippians 4:8”
 

Lisamn

Active member
Dec 29, 2020
795
229
43
again that is what you think but you have not proven your point of pagan worship by default. make sure you turn away from the Super Bowl, world series, Netflix etc.. The context of Christmas is not pagan in the Christian world view it is the birth of Christ. Found in the New Testament known as the word of God. Jesus never said don't honor his birth the decibels never said don't honor his birth. Old Testament Prophecy was fulfilled at HIS Birth. the Promise of the Lord coming was foretold BY God the Father Angel worshiped kings worshiped Shepard's worshiped prophets prophesied the Holy Spirit moved signs in heaven were given. ALL that is in the very word of God if you have found a pagan , Egyptian goddess being worshiped out of all that YOU NEED to start LOOKING AT the BIBLE.


Whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report ... think on these things." Philippians 4:8”
We don’t really even know the actual day of his birth..it isn’t recorded in scripture...so if God want’s us to celebrate His birth...why not add that info. I also don’t read about the disciples setting up their Christmas trees..or even celebrating Jesus’ birthday. And that’s because Jesus didn’t come into the world for us to celebrate His birth. He came into it to save his from sin and that should be our focus. Salvation.

John 3:16
For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that whomsoever believes in Him will not perish but have everlasting life.​

There’s absolutely nothing in that about celebrating the birth of His only begotten Son.

Also..why would we celebrate the birth of God? He is the I Am..the one who was and is and is to come. He is not created like us..why then should we celebrate an immortal beings human birth? After all He is sitting at the right hand of the Father at this moment..

And it is a pagan holiday that was interspersed with fake Christianity i.e. the catholic church.
 

CS1

Well-known member
May 23, 2012
13,006
4,313
113
We don’t really even know the actual day of his birth..it isn’t recorded in scripture...so if God want’s us to celebrate His birth...why not add that info. I also don’t read about the disciples setting up their Christmas trees..or even celebrating Jesus’ birthday. And that’s because Jesus didn’t come into the world for us to celebrate His birth. He came into it to save his from sin and that should be our focus. Salvation.

John 3:16
For God so loved the world that He gave His only begotten Son that whomsoever believes in Him will not perish but have everlasting life.​

There’s absolutely nothing in that about celebrating the birth of His only begotten Son.

Also..why would we celebrate the birth of God? He is the I Am..the one who was and is and is to come. He is not created like us..why then should we celebrate an immortal beings human birth? After all He is sitting at the right hand of the Father at this moment..

And it is a pagan holiday that was interspersed with fake Christianity i.e. the catholic church.
red herring not knowing the day he was born is not reason to celebrate the event.
 

Lisamn

Active member
Dec 29, 2020
795
229
43
red herring not knowing the day he was born is not reason to celebrate the event.
How is it a red herring? If God wanted us to celebrate the birth of Jesus..he would have given us a date, don’t ya think? But that’s not why God sent His Son so we could set up trees and decorate them to celebrate the birth of His Son when we don’t really know the exact day.

Not only that we would have seen christmas being celebrated by them as well...Jesus would have talked about His birthday celebrations but no...He talked about the Father and His death and his followers sharing the Good News. That’s what was meaningful with His coming..

Philippians 2:5-8​
Have this attitude in yourself which was also in Christ Jesus, who, although He existed in the form of God, did not regard equality with God a thing to be grasped, but emptied Himself, taking the form of a bond-servant, and being made in the likeness of men. Being found in appearance as a man, he humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross.
 
Nov 15, 2020
1,897
362
83
Newcastle, NSW, Australia
no, as I said before "XMAS" is the removal of Christ in Christmas. The Advent season, which is the time to reflect and set apart time to commemorate the birth of Jesus, one of the holiest times in the Christian faith. The only time I have heard of "XMAS" was by atheists and non-Christians and those who had to interject a false narrative about Christmas. The Church Historically has set apart times and seasons known as the Advent and that calendar starts with many holy ( set apart) events which all are documented in the word od God.

not from Egypt, not from pagan, but from the Biblical accounts recorded in the Word of God here they are you can tell me which event did not happen in the Bible and use a pagan explanation for what the Bible says :

  1. Christmas = the birth of Christ
  2. The Baptism of the Lord
  3. The transfiguration a
  4. Palm Sunday Jesus's triumphant entry start of holy week
  5. Easter the death Burial and resurrection
  6. the Ascension
  7. Pentecost
IF you want to find pagan rituals and practices in the word of God and associate them with the Birth of Christ please be my guest, however, your argument in wanting to attack the RCC has run over to those who are not even RCC or practice or hold to or taught about the solise pagan beliefs.

There is bad history of the early Church but the birth of Christ and the Advent season is praise-worthy and edifying. Insulting the Mother of Jesus and trying to draw a narrative of an Egyptian goddess which are false and unreal with an actual person a woman who was named Mary a virgin who conceived by the Holy Spirit which the Word of God says ALL men will call you blessed. I will not insult the Lord's Momma. YOu can if you like. BUT don't lie about the association of false goddesses and mary a real person documented in the Biblical account and genealogy of Jesus.
ok, so what is advent ?
And where in the Bible is it ?
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
someone can explain to me the christian significance of Boxing Day then.

Im hanging out for Epiphany