When visitors who are childless sit down to hear mostly screaming babies, it's unlikely they will return, for in their minds that's what that church apparently likes to hear. Well, maybe their services are worse. Probably not.
We've found a near perfect solution. One of our ladies ministries is devoted to young mothers. When a visitor arrives with a baby they are greeted and guided through the two hour stay. It's absolutely amazing that a modern mother might be clueless as to shy their baby cries, while anyone sitting near can small a dirty diaper, or see baby desperately trying to find a drop in a bottle. There's a cry over hunger, and one for boredom, or simply missing it's nap time that time of day. So, each mommy gets invited to where free diapers can be changed, free baby food is available, even free formula milk and new free bottles, and a nursing station.
Toddlers are not allowed to run around in services disturbing people, but have a wonderland of toys, Bible story videos, lite snacks after group lessons. The fastest growing class space demand is for mothers with child. From there bonds are made, allowing some of the ladies to visit homes where they can help fix home problems like providing cooking utensils and cooking lessons. They report issues the men's ministry can go fix. Most every skill and craft is available a day a week, usually Saturdays, at no charge, offered mostly to widows who exhibit the biblical standard in Timothy.
Now, there's sometimes a mommy resisting all that, intent on everyone else suffering through the baby crying. We've learned that's a sign of rebellion of mommy and then of child, and often is linked to a broken home with daddy giving up. We've had lone Daddys left with child, desperate for help. It's easy to find out. Ask. So the preacher will stop his sermon with "Some little one needs Mommy's or Daddy's attention, please answer your child's need." She might not return, but how many others who were seeking something from God won't return?
It's expensive, yes, but any church can do something, as any mother has advice to give.