Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Thank you Jordon, and good day. It is just amazing to me all these distortions of Scripture that are being flung around by people refusing to admit what is plainly written. Or they say, we cannot know (because the Bible does not say) and then insist it could only have happened the way they imagine. LOL. And what they imagine denies what the Scripture verse explicitly articulates. Yes. A bit mind boggling. They contradict themselves all over the place, but this is something I have noticed about people in error, and commented on before. And I believe we saw the height of the general lack of logic among FWers when one said God convinced them of the Truth, and then they got to decide if they believed it or not.
yep mind boggling is the word for today, I mean for not letting things overwhelm you, is to look at the statements of mind boggling lol

and dont let them boggle you 🤩
 
Do not agree that Adam was with Eve when the serpent spoke to her.





Agree.





Do not agree that Adam was with Eve when the serpent spoke to her.





This verse does not state that Adam was with Eve when the serpent beguiled her.

This verse states that Adam was with Eve only when she gave him the fruit.





There is no indication that Adam was with Eve when satan spoke to her.

Your claim that "he didn't stop Eve" (which is an assumption) does not align with your claim that "man is meant to be the head of the woman" (which is true/not an assumption).

What you want me to believe is that Adam stood by ... listened to satan lie to Eve about what God told Adam ... then, without any correction of the lie of satan, Adam stood silent as he allowed Eve to eat in disobedience of Gen 2:17 ... then after that he decided he should eat in obedience to Gen 2:24.

So Adam was disobedient to Gen 2:17 ... but obedient to Gen 2:24 ??? that's what you want me to believe ???

I agree only that Adam ate after Eve ate.





There is no indication in the text that Adam was with Eve when satan beguiled her in order to "lead Eve to follow God's first law" ... so when Adam became aware that Eve had eaten, what Adam did was follow what is written in Gen 2:24.

The text indicates Adam was with Eve only when Eve gave him the fruit.

The text also indicates that Adam hearkened to the voice of his wife ... Adam did not hearken to the serpent. If Adam had been present when the serpent spoke to Eve, would Adam not have "hearkened" to the voice of the serpent as Eve had done? ... or stopped Eve from eating?

No, that wily, sneaky, despicable satan approached Eve when she was away from Adam and he deceived her with cunning craftiness.
.

Neither is there any "indication in the text" that Adam showed up on the scene only after Eve was tempted. You're reading that into the text. But the natural reading is that Adam was with Eve when the serpent approached her.
 
yep mind boggling is the word for today, I mean for not letting things overwhelm you, is to look at the statements of mind boggling lol

and dont let them boggle you 🤩
Part of this most recent boondoggle is who is doing this. But it is not like it has not happened before. Even Paul was betrayed
and of course of preeminent consideration is the fact that Jesus Christ was betrayed by those in His inner circle.
 
Neither is there any "indication in the text" that Adam showed up on the scene only after Eve was tempted. You're reading that into the text. But the natural reading is that Adam was with Eve when the serpent approached her.
She took some of its fruit and ate it; she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it.

Pretty plainly spoken... and we can see who disagrees with plainly spoken Scripture. Hardly surprising!

They prefer the machinations of their God-blaspheming imagination.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cameron143
All these rabbit holes trying to obscure the fact that the Bible does not say Jonah slept within the whale.
Eerrrrr do you not recall @posthuman listing a few dozen passages confirming that in relevant context "sleep" is synonymous with "physical death"?

You know, "reading" the Bible is an art as well as a science......:sneaky:
 
satan used guile on Eve only.





Adam did what is instructed in Gen 2:24.





The offering by God was for both Adam and Eve ... both were clothed by God ... do you believe God's offering was insufficient for both Adam and Eve?





satan is the one who let her eat ... Adam was not present when satan beguiled Eve.





Adam left his Father to join his wife and become one flesh with her (Gen 2:24).
.

So...you believe in efficacious atonement after all, don't you? All it took was for God to clothe them with the skins of slain animals. No faith, no repentance, no confession of sins necessary. Then how come you don't believe in efficacious atonement in Christ's atoning work on the Cross? Instead, you and other FWers are quite content to play word games: Christ died for the sins of all humanity w/o exception, BUT (here's comes the BUT(T) Monkey)...But of course people have meet the gospel conditions and confess their sins, repent of them and trust in Christ. Jesus' atoning work simply makes it POSSIBLE to be saved. Jesus is the POTENTIAL savior of all mankind.

Can you not see your own duplicity here? According to FWers, God clearly saved A&E on an entirely different basis than He did at the Cross of Christ. In the first case, God's atoning provision of animal skins was 100% efficacious with no conditions placed on A&E, while in the second the Christ's atoning work is 0% efficacious since man must obey the conditions of the gospel BEFORE Christ's work actually can save them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rogerg
She took some of its fruit and ate it; she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it.

Pretty plainly spoken... and we can see who disagrees with plainly spoken Scripture. Hardly surprising!

They prefer the machinations of their God-blaspheming imagination.

FWers will break their own backs in trying to put Adam in a positive light. They slink into 100% Spin Mode! They know scripture speaks only negatively about Adam, so they feel they have to educate God and set Him straight by giving Him the real, inside skinny on what went on in the Garden. :rolleyes:
 
Part of this most recent boondoggle is who is doing this. But it is not like it has not happened before. Even Paul was betrayed
and of course of preeminent consideration is the fact that Jesus Christ was betrayed by those in His inner circle.
Well there's tons tons of scriptures I could cite of tons different people selling themselves to sin.

But i really don't have the time but if you place them in line from Adam you see the same pattern emerging over and over again.

It only then that mind boggling things being said about Adam can be looked in the light they actually are, which is people selling themselves to sin
 
Evidently Adam could not be outsmarted by the second smartest creature of all creation.

Makes perfect sense oui?

But your superhero Adam did a superb, stellar, spectacular job in outsmarting himself, didn't he!? Ever hear of self-deception? :rolleyes:
 
Male and female created He them, in the image of God, that is, as judges, but it just so happens the first opportunity presented them to judge righteously, they dropped the righteous ball. This is, "her husband with her" and who "listened to the voice of your wife." Adam judged, even though he wasn't deceived, he judged "with her" what she had judged, "that the fruit was good for food and...". , i.e. he concurred with her ruling. I'm speculating now in thinking that, perhaps, "I know it will kill me but, if I gain the knowledge of God, I'll be able to figure out how to conquer death..." without realizing that only the death of the righteous could overcome the death of the wicked. :unsure: just some thoughts.
 
i think you talk like you despise the Lord's chastening.

930 years isn't even one day in the sight of God.

Cain murdered his brother, and his punishment? bad at farming.

tell me more about how unfair you consider God to be lol

Well...in government work that would be close enough... :coffee:
 
Male and female created He them, in the image of God, that is, as judges, but it just so happens the first opportunity presented them to judge righteously, they dropped the righteous ball. This is, "her husband with her" and who "listened to the voice of your wife." Adam judged, even though he wasn't deceived, he judged "with her" what she had judged, "that the fruit was good for food and...". , i.e. he concurred with her ruling. I'm speculating now in thinking that, perhaps, "I know it will kill me but, if I gain the knowledge of God, I'll be able to figure out how to conquer death..." without realizing that only the death of the righteous could overcome the death of the wicked. :unsure: just some thoughts.

Good post! Pride is at the root of every sin! Pride is what caused Lucifer to fall, and it's what caused Adam to fall. What both Satan and Adam wanted was to be just like God...if indeed not better!
 
Context, bro. Are you dead serious here === you truly believe Adam actually died when God put him in a sleep to make Eve?

And the LORD God caused a deep sleep to fall upon Adam, and he slept:
and he took one of his ribs, and closed up the flesh instead thereof;


Sounds more like anesthetic-type sleep for surgery...

But you are making the case that Adam died???

I suppose the FWers are now trying to make their hero Adam the Firstborn from the dead in their never ending quest to show us just how upright and fearless and brave he was. I wonder if the Great Physician operated on Adam with or without his consent? :rolleyes:
 
8639. tardemah
Lexical Summary
tardemah: Deep sleep, trance


Original Word: תַּרְדֵּמָה
Part of Speech: Noun Feminine
Transliteration: tardemah
Pronunciation: tar-day-maw'
Phonetic Spelling: (tar-day-maw')
KJV: deep sleep
NASB: deep sleep, sound sleep
Word Origin: [from H7290 (רָדַם - To sleep deeply)]


1. a lethargy
2. (by implication) trance
Strong's Exhaustive Concordance
deep sleep
From radam; a lethargy or (by implication) trance -- deep sleep.
see HEBREW radam



Genesis 2:21
HEB: עַל־ הָאָדָ֖ם וַיִּישָׁ֑ן וַיִּקַּ֗ח אַחַת֙
NAS: upon the man, and he slept; then He took
KJV: upon Adam, and he slept: and he took
INT: upon the man slept took one

C'mon, Magenta, everyone in the world knows that DEATH is truly the wages of surgery (whether AMA-approved or not). Adam the Innocent suffered unjustly suffered death at the hands of his Surgeon. :rolleyes:
 
Male and female created He them, in the image of God, that is, as judges, but it just so happens the first opportunity presented them to judge righteously, they dropped the righteous ball. This is, "her husband with her" and who "listened to the voice of your wife." Adam judged, even though he wasn't deceived, he judged "with her" what she had judged, "that the fruit was good for food and...". , i.e. he concurred with her ruling. I'm speculating now in thinking that, perhaps, "I know it will kill me but, if I gain the knowledge of God, I'll be able to figure out how to conquer death..." without realizing that only the death of the righteous could overcome the death of the wicked. :unsure: just some thoughts.

Instead of listening to and heeding the voice of God's prophetic warning (Gen 2:16-17). And not a thing has changed down through the ages, has it? We have thoroughly self-deceived FWers here who constantly read their presuppositions into passages and swear this is what God has said! :rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: rogerg
So then is this prayer was made as he anticipated his death inside the fish?
That would make sense to me, him dying but then God bringing him back to life.

Jonah 2:1-9
Jonah literally said that he was in Sheol.

And somebody PLEASE inform @Magenta @Cameron143 @Jordon @Rufus that the "sign of Jonah" is.... drumroll.....

THE RESURRECTION......!

I mean that is exactly what Jesus is saying when He refers the the "sign of Jonah". Physical death then whoops resurrected.

Jonah. Dead. Resurrected. Christ. Dead. Resurrected.

And these people that don't understand this infallible biblical fact spoken by Jesus Himself are NOT biblical illiterate?
 
if that was an invitation, I guess I should consider, but I'm thinking it may have been but im not sure with you, and my guard goes up when people just repeat expressions of faith, then not even acknowledging its the lord faith there expressing, especially when it comes to saying all they have to do is believe, as they can't believe by themselves,

But it Diffacult to know really if it was an invitation.
The other thing is I have a hard time talking with people who can't accept God can go against there will, it's not that I have a hard time, it's just that it becomes a consuming one.

I have no idea why my saying "Do you agree with those and also with my commentary that cites quite a few Scriptures?" is not a clear invitation to discuss what I posted, which was:

{{{A crisis that threatened a Philippian jailer with death prompted him to ask Paul and Silas the most important question in life: “What must I do to be saved?” (Acts 16:30) This question is most important, because—as sinful and mortal souls—we need saving from corruption, both moral and physical. We need saving from physical death if we value or enjoy life, and we need saving from immorality or evil-doing if it results in unhappy existence, especially after this lifetime.

The reply of Paul and Silas was this: “Believe in the Lord Jesus.” (Acts 16:31) This is GRFS in a nutshell. Jesus Himself expressed GRFS even more succinctly using three, four and five letter words: “Ask… seek… knock…” (Matt. 7:7). This indicates that God graces every sinful soul with the ability or opportunity to seek salvation (cf. 1Tim. 2:3-4, Ezek. 33:11), which might be called “seeking grace” (Tit. 2:11). As Hebrews 11:6 states: “he [God] rewards those who earnestly seek him” (cf. Isa. 45:19). Seeking God is the beginning of saving faith, and not seeking God or rejecting His salvation in Christ is the essence of evil atheism or faith in I-dolatry (Rom. 3:11, 1:18-23). All humans sin, but every sinner has the opportunity to repent/have saving faith (per Rom. 1:20, 2:7, 3:21-22, 4:16 & 5:8-19).

The only law in that reply was “Believe in the Lord Jesus.” (Acts 16:31) and maybe “he [God] rewards those who earnestly seek him” (Heb. 11:6). Do you agree with those and also with my commentary that cites quite a few Scriptures?}}}
 
Jonah literally said that he was in Sheol.
well I don't know, I mean Johna could have said anything covered in whale guts and all sorts of things for 3 days.
But how can he be literally there when he was disobeying God.
even if he was there was it a dream whilst he was sleeping

It could have been God transporting him there spiritually to show him is errors