Can We Really Exercise Free Will?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
If God desires everyone to be saved, but some aren't ultimately saved because of their freewill choice, how is that a success for God?
Because if that's how God created it and it works out that way then it's 100% successful.
 
Phil1:18 does address the motives of the proclaimer. But what's the point of proclamation you fail to see and the reason Paul rejoices in it?. He rejoices in proclamation, because the proclamation of Christ carries power - and the Spirit works with it to convict. Paul’s looking for volition under every rock. He rejoices that Christ is preached, even from improper motives, because the message still reaches the unsaved. Volitional belief is the point of proclamation.
I thought you believed individuals are under conviction. Wouldn't volitional choice come when conviction promotes a saving choice or fails to do so?
 
So, is that what John is teaching in 1Jn 5:18: That the "whole world" which is under the devil's control is limited to those OF the world"?
Satan needed permission and specifics to what he could do to Job.
 
Luke says convicted unbelievers received the word (Acts2:41), which is a real volitional response to God’s initiative.
That is not what Luke said despite your lies to the contrary.

Unfortunately you love adding to and also taking away from what is actually said.

It is a real problem with FWers, open theists, Hebrew roots etc.
 
I thought you believed individuals are under conviction. Wouldn't volitional choice come when conviction promotes a saving choice or fails to do so?

The Gospel and the Spirit put unbelievers under conviction—or, translated another way, work to convince them of Truth. They do not fail, but faithfully present Truth for the unbeliever to choose to believe or to reject.
 
The Gospel and the Spirit put unbelievers under conviction—or, translated another way, work to convince them
of Truth. They do not fail, but faithfully present Truth for the unbeliever to choose to believe or to reject.
The unbeliever who can neither receive nor comprehend, or the one who can?

Because there is a difference most FWers fail to grasp. Most if not all.

Which is why they continually conflate the unregenerated man with the spiritual man.

And it is in fact the line free willers cannot cross in their adherence to their idol.

Then again you love to mock the idea of people being spiritually dead in need of new life in Christ.

Which is truly quite baffling. It is like you fail to grasp even the rudiments of Christianity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blain
The unbeliever who can neither receive nor comprehend, or the one who can?

Because there is a difference most FWers fail to grasp. Most if not all.

Which is why they continually conflate the unregenerated man with the spiritual man.

And it is in fact the line free willers cannot cross in their adherence to their idol.

Then again you love to mock the idea of people being spiritually dead in need of new life in Christ.

Which is truly quite baffling. It is like you fail to grasp even the rudiments of Christianity.
If people cannot seperate the spiritual dead man with the spiritually born again man then they need to get back to the basics becausue the natural man has no inkling of the things of God not spiritually anyways they can study the bible and get knowledge of God but to percieve the things of God one must be born again period
 
  • Like
Reactions: BillyBob
If He could use one dumb ass, then He can use all of them for His purposes if He wanted to.

[2Pe 2:16 KJV] 16 But was rebuked for his iniquity: the dumb ass speaking with man's voice forbad the madness of the prophet.
That's one way of looking at I guess.

But Regardless of what condition. Of numbness a person is in or at with a heart of stone.

What's your thoughts on all people being born with heart of stone.

Baring in mind I've already pointed out it's not just a bad thing.

Simply put if being born with a heart of stone was just a bad thing none would be saved in my view.
 
If people cannot seperate the spiritual dead man with the spiritually born again man then they need to get back to the basics becausue the natural man has no inkling of the things of God not spiritually anyways they can study the bible and get knowledge of God but to percieve the things of God one must be born again period
Which is why they need to strip 1 Cor 2:14 of its true meaning and rewrite it to suit their programmed way of thinking.

Though really that verse is just one nail in the coffin of their idol. There are plenty, and they treat them all similarly.

Like Romans 8:7, and John 14:17. Where God's Word says "can't" or "cannot" they say "can."
 
"Truer words were never spoken"

Amen!

When are you leaving!?

I was very busy yesterday but did read one of your posts wherein you essentially stated God while God loves all men in the world [in the distributive sense], He especially loves believers. You, too, have so little awareness (if any) of the implications to what you write!

First of all, your statement qualified God's love to believers, since it's perfectly logical to infer that God does NOT love the wicked in the same manner as the saints! Therefore, you have limited God's special love to one particular group of people: Believers! In so doing, you have unwittingly admitted that God does, after all, love people unequally!

A second serious implication to your ill-conceived notion is that God is very confused and conflicted; for on one hand He loves all wicked mankind unconditionally, yet at the same time He also loves his saints conditionally! He loves his saints because they are believers, God-Fearers, righteous and love His Son -- all of which are conditions!

It appears you have little or no affinity for biblical truth or for sound logic!

P.S. Don't let the door hit ya on the way out...
 
First of all, your statement qualified God's love to believers, since it's perfectly logical to infer that God does NOT love the wicked in the same manner as the saints! Therefore, you have limited God's special love to one particular group of people: Believers! In so doing, you have unwittingly admitted that God does, after all, love people unequally!
Considering how often she has told us how unfair God is if He is not the same from one person to the next...

Ah, well, we are just back to how they can hardly help contradicting themselves when they are so steeped in error.

Perhaps when they use that free will to choose which socks to wear, they should choose those with a non-slip grip.
 
God replaces the heart of stone because it is incurably wicked.
Determinist hogwash.

[Luk 15:7 KJV] 7 I say unto you, that likewise joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth, more than over ninety and nine just persons, which need no repentance.
 
Volitional belief is simply Scriptural. Commands to believe require volitional responses. Your willingness to slander Christians does not speak well of you, nor of the errant tradition you sinfully support to such a degree.

False! Heart-held, heart-felt belief "is simply Scriptural"! Has God promised in the New Covenant made with his covenant people that He would equip them with a new volition or a new heart? Or has God promised to circumcise his chosen people's volitions or their hearts?
 
you wrote a tome to prove that believers are also right now under the control of Satan right along with the wicked of the world -- the very one whom Jesus came into this world to currently defeat for his people in this age. Another epic fail for Jesus! Another promise not kept!
believers are victims of satan when they fail to stand strong in faith against the wiles of the devil ... and if and when that happens, God has given instruction to the born again one ...

1 John 1:9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

and that does not negate the fact that when we sin it is due to being drawn away from the Lord ... and drawn to the things of this world which is under the control of satan.

and don't tell me you don't sin because that would make you a liar ...

1 John 1:

8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.

...

10 If we say that we have not sinned, we make him a liar, and his word is not in us.
.
 
Determinist hogwash.

[Luk 15:7 KJV] 7 I say unto you, that likewise joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repenteth, more than over ninety and nine just persons, which need no repentance.

Repentance, too, is a gift of God! The very essence of the precious gift of the Fear of the Lord is that those who possess this gift shun, avoid and turn from evil! So, this is very good news for God's elect. The bad news for you FWers is that this gift was never promised to the world at large. It was promised only to God's covenant people!
 
Your willingness to slander Christians does not speak well of you
plank.png

plank
 
Which is why they need to strip 1 Cor 2:14 of its true meaning and rewrite it to suit their programmed way of thinking.

Though really that verse is just one nail in the coffin of their idol. There are plenty, and they treat them all similarly.

Like Romans 8:7, and John 14:17. Where God's Word says "can't" or "cannot" they say "can."
Yep the scriptures are very clear you literally have to rewrite it to make it say something else in order for them to have their ideas and understanding fit.
I mean it literally says it right there I do not see or understand how one can not accept this as truth it doesn't even make sense