Once saved always saved (OSAS) debunked

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,681
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,681
Runningman said:
Peter is talking about people such as Judas Iscariot who lost their salvation after at one point obtaining it.
Click to expand...
@Runningman: "As a result, Jesus one time said to Judas he would have eternal life."
@Runningman: Yet Jesus never called Judas an unbeliever. That's because Judas was a believer and the New Testament proves it.
@Runningman: "Peter is talking about people such as Judas Iscariot who lost their salvation after at one point obtaining it."
@Runningman: "Judas repented. I’ll never move from that despite your repeated attempts to gaslight me into thinking otherwise."
@Runningman: "Paul said this repentance is the kind of repentance that comes from sorrow, just as God intended. Judas had it. "
@Runningman: "Of course, you wouldn’t have Judas doing anything right even though the Bible says otherwise. It’s just part of your narrative that Judas never repented when the Bible says he did.

So now you are saying that Judas WAS undoubtedly saved, then somehow LOST his salvation, and then REGAINED it after "repenting"?
You are all over the map. Please help us out with a cogent reply to this seemingly paradoxical quandary.
 
R

Runningman

Banned
#2,682
Mar 4, 2020
8,614
3,691
113
#2,682
cv5 said:
@Runningman: "As a result, Jesus one time said to Judas he would have eternal life."
@Runningman: Yet Jesus never called Judas an unbeliever. That's because Judas was a believer and the New Testament proves it.
@Runningman: "Peter is talking about people such as Judas Iscariot who lost their salvation after at one point obtaining it."
@Runningman: "Judas repented. I’ll never move from that despite your repeated attempts to gaslight me into thinking otherwise."
@Runningman: "Paul said this repentance is the kind of repentance that comes from sorrow, just as God intended. Judas had it. "
@Runningman: "Of course, you wouldn’t have Judas doing anything right even though the Bible says otherwise. It’s just part of your narrative that Judas never repented when the Bible says he did.

So now you are saying that Judas WAS undoubtedly saved, then somehow LOST his salvation, and then REGAINED it after "repenting"?
You are all over the map. Please help us out with a cogent reply to this seemingly paradoxical quandary.
Click to expand...
What I say is found in the Bible and what you say isn't. You said Judas never repented and I proved he did. You should be the one defending yourself here.
 
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,683
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,683
Runningman said:
What I say is found in the Bible and what you say isn't. You said Judas never repented and I proved he did. You should be the one defending yourself here.
Click to expand...
Let's just count the green checkmarks at the end of the day and leave it at that. Shall we?
 
R

Runningman

Banned
#2,684
Mar 4, 2020
8,614
3,691
113
#2,684
cv5 said:
Let's just count the green checkmarks at the end of the day and leave it at that. Shall we?
Click to expand...
Enioy your praise from people; your reward is fake Internet points. I'll take my praise from God.
 
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,685
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,685
Runningman said:
Enioy your praise from people; your reward is fake Internet points. I'll take my praise from God.
Click to expand...
I do not see a lot of green checkmarks coming from God by calling His Son a liar and disputing His Word of prophecy.
But have it your way.
 
R

Runningman

Banned
#2,686
Mar 4, 2020
8,614
3,691
113
#2,686
cv5 said:
I do not see a lot of green checkmarks coming from God by calling His Son a liar and disputing His Word of prophecy.
But have it your way.
Click to expand...
Why sacrifice your integrity just to say false things about me? You’re in this for your glory. It’s clear if you can make me out to be some kind of aggressor toward Jesus then you can get more fake internet points. Been seeing that a lot lately; don’t let this website get to your head, it isn’t worth it.

You’re on a sinking ship cv5. You need to repent.
 
HeIsHere

HeIsHere

Well-known member
#2,687
May 21, 2022
5,800
2,258
113
#2,687
cv5 said:
That is exactly what the Bible says of the elect. Hope you can wrap your head around it.
Click to expand...

The bible states the plan of salvation was laid down before the foundation of the world not that people were chosen before the foundation of the world.
 
Magenta

Magenta

Senior Member
#2,689
Jul 3, 2015
59,815
29,195
113
#2,689
cv5 said:
So now you are saying that Judas WAS undoubtedly saved, then somehow LOST his salvation, and then REGAINED it after "repenting"?
You are all over the map. Please help us out with a cogent reply to this seemingly paradoxical quandary.
Click to expand...
Clearly it is a case of "Jesus was wrong to call Judas a 'son of perdition'."
 
HeIsHere

HeIsHere

Well-known member
#2,690
May 21, 2022
5,800
2,258
113
#2,690
wattie said:
Yeah.. eternal salvation has always been faith in the Messiah. Whether to come.. or looking back at Him when He came. Job believed in a redeemer.. so did David.. among others. They weren't made righteous by their good works.. but God made them righteous by their belief in Him.

The system of service was in the Old Testament laws.. but those laws never eternally saved them. That is what the Pharisees and Scribese didn't get.
Click to expand...
If this were so then the sacrifice of Jesus would not have been necessary.

I see that scripture is clear, those who believed God before the resurrection were accredited with righteousness, even though they had not obtained the promise, those after the resurrection were made righteous through the blood of Jesus and obtained the promise. So Jesus after his death descended to those who were in the bosom of Abraham and brought freedom to them.

As well consider Saul, the Spirit would come upon him one minute and he would prophecy, and the next minute Satan would enter him and he would try to kill David.

John 20 makes clear when the apostles were born again into the New Covenant.

22 And when he had said this, He breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit.

Was Thomas saved? He didn't believe until he saw,
 
Magenta

Magenta

Senior Member
#2,692
Jul 3, 2015
59,815
29,195
113
#2,692
HeIsHere said:
Lost his standing.

How does one loose their standing when the standing is based on someone else's work?
Click to expand...
Perhaps the question should be, how can one lose something they never had in the first place?

Judas did not believe and therefore never possessed eternal life/salvation.

For Jesus had known from the beginning which of them did not believe and who would betray him. John 6:64b
 
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,693
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,693
HeIsHere said:
The bible states the plan of salvation was laid down before the foundation of the world not that people were chosen before the foundation of the world.
Click to expand...
Nope.

Eph 1:4
"According as he hath chosen us in Him before the foundation of the world...."
 
R

Runningman

Banned
#2,694
Mar 4, 2020
8,614
3,691
113
#2,694
HeIsHere said:
Lost his standing.

How does one loose their standing when the standing is based on someone else's work?
Click to expand...
Great question and it’s a valid one.

Judas Iscariot is either OSAS or he lost his salvation. Well, we know from Matthew 19 that those who leave their life and follow Jesus will inherit eternal life. So Judas checks that box.

However, Judas committed apostasy, betrayed Jesus, and though he repented of betraying innocent blood, he committed suicide.

Finally, the prophecy plainly states he was doomed to destruction. Destruction is the punishment reserved for the unsaved.

So it’s quite conclusive that Judas lost eternal life. It also meshes with scripture quite well. It seems it’s possible some are destined to be destroyed. There’s a doctrine for this. Though I am only beginning to learn predestination.
 
HeIsHere

HeIsHere

Well-known member
#2,695
May 21, 2022
5,800
2,258
113
#2,695
Runningman said:
Great question and it’s a valid one.

Judas Iscariot is either OSAS or he lost his salvation. Well, we know from Matthew 19 that those who leave their life and follow Jesus will inherit eternal life. So Judas checks that box.

However, Judas committed apostasy, betrayed Jesus, and though he repented of betraying innocent blood, he committed suicide.

Finally, the prophecy plainly states he was doomed to destruction. Destruction is the penalty reserves for the unsaved.

So it’s quite conclusive that Judas lost eternal life. It also meshes with scripture quite well. It seems it’s possible some are destined to be destroyed.
Click to expand...

You are funny. :D

#2690 <<<<<

I think I cut through this debate in this post, read it now!! :D
 
R

Runningman

Banned
#2,696
Mar 4, 2020
8,614
3,691
113
#2,696
HeIsHere said:
Lost his standing.

How does one loose their standing when the standing is based on someone else's work?
Click to expand...
To add a bit more to my previous response, John 6 Peter said of the 12 “we” believe.

Mark 6, Judas is chosen by Jesus and given authority to cast out devils and heal. Judas wasn’t a devil yet, despite prophecy ultimately making him one.

Also, Mark 16 is clear only those who believe can cast out devils and heal.

Judas checked many desirable boxes that many Christians today can’t quite get yet.

It’s because they aren’t focusing on giving God glory, but maybe I’ll open up a thread later on how to be blessed with these gifts. I have a few myself.
 
HeIsHere

HeIsHere

Well-known member
#2,697
May 21, 2022
5,800
2,258
113
#2,697
cv5 said:
Nope.

Eph 1:4
"According as he hath chosen us in Him before the foundation of the world...."
Click to expand...
I was thinking of a different verse but the one you posted is about God predetermining what will become of those who are in Christ through belief in His truth.

Then we also have this line...

“…when you heard the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation.”
 
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,698
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,698
cv5

cv5

Well-known member
#2,699
Nov 20, 2018
22,754
8,265
113
#2,699
HeIsHere

HeIsHere

Well-known member
#2,700
May 21, 2022
5,800
2,258
113
#2,700
Runningman said:
To add a bit more to my previous response, John 6 Peter said of the 12 “we” believe.

Mark 6, Judas is chosen by Jesus and given authority to cast out devils and heal. Judas wasn’t a devil yet, despite prophecy ultimately making him one.

Also, Mark 16 is clear only those who believe can cast out devils and heal.

Judas checked many desirable boxes that many Christians today can’t quite get yet.

It’s because they aren’t focusing on giving God glory, but maybe I’ll open up a thread later on how to be blessed with these gifts. I have a few myself.
Click to expand...

My point the New Covenant did not begin until after Christ rose from the dead, so to speak of of Judas as saved or not saved is a straw man argument.

We do know that those born again in the new covenant have the more excellent ministry (Hebrews), they are sealed in the righteousness of Jesus.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.