What are Your Thoughts About Financially Independent Women?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Gideon300

Well-known member
Mar 18, 2021
5,441
3,222
113
so being dependent is FEMININE? while being independent is Masculine?

what

lol

interesting....or rather...implausible. I would just think its a matter of being grown up.
Independence is much overrated. Woman submits to husband, husband submits to Christ. No room for independence there. It's just another word for rebellion.
 

Gideon300

Well-known member
Mar 18, 2021
5,441
3,222
113
My goodness, Treeboy, I have read a few of your posts and I'm sorry for whatever you've been through, but you always come across as sounding like a venomous snake towards women. Posts like yours are exactly why I pay for the guy on the first date, even if he asked -- so that he can't come back and say I used him for anything.

You might take the time to notice that this thread's original post is actually written from the opposite frame of mind of what you're describing. And it was meant to give people hope that there are alternatives to life rather than placing all your bets on finding one magical person. It might not mean finding the life you thought you wanted, but it might mean finding a different, and just as meaningful, life.

The other day I remembered an old song (doctored to my situation) that described exactly how I felt when my then-husband left: "I got time while (he) got freedom... 'Cause when a heart breaks, no it don't break even."

I couldn't understand why he had found the freedom to run off with this girl, while I felt like I had been sentenced to Life Without Parole in Solitary Confinement. One of my biggest sorrows was thinking, "How will I ever be able to go anywhere (travel) without a husband?" But I learned how to get around that -- by using all my spare time to work, save up everything I could, and find awesome single, responsible friends who are able to travel together, including going on cruises. And I no longer worry about dying alone. I've lived several decades of my life around senior citizens, and I've seen that having a spouse and even children or grandchildren is still no guarantee that one won't die alone.

At the very least, you could wind up outliving all the ones who were willing to have anything to do with you, which I've seen happen.

As far as having things to offer a man... The last time I went to buy a car, the guy who went to check my credit came back and told the salesperson to be nice to me because my credit score was higher than his, lol. The thing was, I didn't even need a credit score because I bought the car in cash. Granted, that was nearly 10 years ago and the car still runs perfectly so there's no need to replace it, but when I do, I'll have saved enough to buy the next one in cash as well. And I know several other women who are either in, or approaching, this category as well.

I hope the guys out there don't believe that every woman is a soul-sucking, gold-digging vampire as described in your post. Sheesh.

And none of this is to try to give myself any credit -- I just tried my best to listen to Godly counsel. And the whole point of this thread was to get a conversation started about being different from the rest of the world and the stereotypes that others try to pigeonhole us into. I'm trying to encourage singles, both men and women, to break out of the boxes that both society and the church try to shove us into, because we can be something different.

I do agree that everyone, both men and women, need to bring something to the table when seeking a relationship. We live in a culture where even in Christian circles, it feels like it's all take and no give, and of course, that's not how God wants us to be.

But I often ask myself what the balance is between what God expects our own expectations to be vs. how much we should also be willing to sacrifice, especially since so many people have fallen upon such tough times, and one of the pillars of the Christian life is to "deny ourselves."
The problem that men find in the Western world is that the system is loaded against them. That is a recipe for bitterness and resentment, great evils that poison them. It will spew out at any opportunity and turns people away. Been there, done that. My ex ignored a court ruling and disappeared with my two children. Her last words were that I was just the biological father. She told me 15 years later that she lied to the kids to shut them up, saying that it was my choice not to see them. I was compelled to pay child support to kids I did not see grow up (they were 8 and 6 when this happened.) Not every marriage ends so messily, but there are plenty of cases where men suffered more than I did. There was not a great deal of property to settle, so I was not ripped off in that way.

It took a couple of years to come to terms with this situation. I had tremendous help from a brother in Christ. I also knew the principle of forgiveness from the heart, not just the mind. When (miraculously) I met my ex again, after 15 years, there was no bitterness or resentment. I was able to meet my now grown children. God is able to restore the years the locusts have eaten.

The root of the problem is expectations. If you are looking for a life partner to meet all your emotional needs, you are in trouble already. No one is that good. We have a place in our inner being that only God can fill. Once we are satisfied with Jesus, we will not seek the impossible from a spouse.
 

Lanolin

Well-known member
Dec 15, 2018
23,460
7,188
113
Independence is much overrated. Woman submits to husband, husband submits to Christ. No room for independence there. It's just another word for rebellion.
we are all dependent, independence is an illusion!

ok thats sorted. next.
 
Aug 28, 2020
79
24
8
Men are waking up to strong independent i dont need a man for nothing attitudes in the west. It was sold as hey young man u will benefit. No alimony less childsupport more money to pay bills. How can u argue with that. However none of those things have happened. In my state there were multiple public court cases where a licensed practicing fulltime female doctor was awarded alimony from her exhusband. Career women actually receive the most child support of any demographic. Women with college degrees top the divorce initiation rate.

As a man it is no fun to live with a woman who goes to work listens to and does everything her boss says for years. It never crosses her mind shes not going to do what her boss tells her. Then she comes home and will not listen to a word you say. Does not care if you are happy at all. Millions of women have been selling this to men for decades. Recently it has turned into my way or the highway from independent women. Men are taking the highway.

Women iced men out to accept this deal for decades. With no other options they took it. After decades they can see the results and many are not interested. Either bring something of value to men to the table or b prepared to die alone. You should retitle this to i want to die alone whos with me.
Yes to all this. Unless if you're a Chad, it is very difficult for men to go out with women. We don't have a problem with women that are independent. That's not what we have a problem with. We don't like to be beaten down, belittled, and demonized just because we don't meet standards that many women (not all of them) setup. Many of them say they want a good man who love and care for them, someone that will treat them good, but at their most honest, these women want a guy that's taller than them, makes a six figure income, a 9 or 10 for physical looks, and a bad boy attitude.

If they settle for those don't get those features, those guys are slapped with so many rules, regulations, and boundaries that if they break one, the relationship is over. In addition to that, the guy sacrifices much of his time and money, with hardly any left for himself, just to keep the relationship to his woman somewhat happy. Even then, these women are still not satisfied. They'll keep these men around until they find the "better deal."

If there are kids involved, why would a strong financially independent woman need alimony from a guy they say is a dead beat? To me, it doesn't sound like they're independent, and what ends up happening with that alimony is it doesn't go towards the children. It go towards the selfish things that these type of women want: designer clothes, a brand new sports car, a giant home, luxurious vacations, etc. The men have no say as to how the alimony is allocated. It's a bad deal across the board.

Again, it's not all women that do this. However, all this stuff that these kind of women setup for normal guys, NONE OF IT applies to the Chads out there. Those kind of men can do, say, and act however they want, as far as these women are concerned. They practically worship these type of men, and what's sad is these guys treat women horribly, but they continue to desire and pursue them. Those women, even after a nasty break up, NEVER let them go. They go as far as trying to get them back.

Some of the ladies and males on here will say "THAT'S NOT TRUE, WHY WOULD THEY GO BACK TO THEM?" As mentioned in the last paragraph, they worship Chad and believe they are entitled to them. The last woman I dated was engaged to such a man. Every condemnation of the guy was always followed up by a compliment or two. She even stayed in contact with the guy, even after the 5-7 year period since they had called off their engagement. The guy took her money, lied to her, manipulated her, misled her, took advantage of her, and even forced himself onto her (the details are graphic, too). I never met the guy, but everything this woman and her sister told me, he was not a good person. According to her sister, the engagement ring this guy got the woman I dated was a fake, but he didn't do much to convince this woman that it was real. Even after the breakup, she carried the ring around, as if it was a reminder of some beautiful thing she lost, even though it was based on a lie.

So if any woman here is truly strong financially and independent, that's great. Truthfully: men don't care. The average guy doesn't think about how much a woman makes. We care more about the relationships we want to be in. As followers in Christ, we care about the relationships that God had set up for us. One of the most important aspects of this is a woman respecting and submitting to a man. It doesn't mean that God wants women to be slaves for us. Not at all. What it means is we want to have value in the relationship, and if women want men to lead and take the brunt of the responsibility, ladies, you have to follow through in what we need you to do. We will love you because not only it's a command that God had set up, but also we like to be desired and valued. And it feels good when a woman enjoys having us around and actually cares about us.

But, just as this man implying, men are at a massive disadvantage. The men at the very top are the only ones many women want, and it drives average guys out of the dating world. Many of them are good men. Good women who actually want good men are then stuck with horrible guys to choose from because the decent males are afraid and fed up to even try anymore. Maybe if these strong financially independent women overhauled their standards and preferences, they'd find good godly men. Some food for thought.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
How did you miss Kauko, in this forum? He was ALL about the woman being financially dependent on him. o_O

And yeah, there are guys like him in real life.
This thread is too long to read. Heck, Seoul's OP was too long to read. So heck no, I didn't read Kauko's post. Sounds hilarious. Maybe you can lynx-me to it?

Besides Kauko, you hear lots of people you know personally having a problem with women being financially independent? Didn't think so. It's not an issue, except for Kauko. lol
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,725
9,656
113
This thread is too long to read. Heck, Seoul's OP was too long to read. So heck no, I didn't read Kauko's post. Sounds hilarious. Maybe you can lynx-me to it?

Besides Kauko, you hear lots of people you know personally having a problem with women being financially independent? Didn't think so. It's not an issue, except for Kauko. lol
Believe me, it IS an issue. Kauko just became (briefly) infamous here in the forum for harping on it so long.

https://christianchat.com/christian...ere-single-christian-girls-in-finland.200207/

48 pages long, so get ready for a long read. But you asked for it. :p

Basically he wants to find a meek, dependent girl who will worship him and never go out of his sight.
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
have no problem with women being financially independent.Nor men.The real concern, is do they have faith in god?We have to lose the world view of things.We will one day feel bad about the faith we put in into money.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
It can be a tough concept/conversation for some in the Christian community.

I find that many people still want to have the traditional male breadwinner/female homemaker scenario, sometimes in a loving way and sometimes in a controlling way, but even if it's all done out of love and reverence for God, that doesn't answer the question of what the wife will do if/when her husband becomes disabled, can't find a job (or a job that will support them all,) is too ill to work (physically and/or mentally,) or dies before she does.

A while back I wrote a thread asking the men if they felt they could earn enough to support a stay-at-home wife and children. Many said they could.

But then when I wrote another thread asking what would happen if they died and left their wife with all the bills and their children with no means of support...

Well.

You could pretty much hear crickets chirping.

There seems to be a vein of people who believe in women staying at home with no work experience, no income of their own, and little to no experience with budgets or paying bills, but when life happens, and we all know it does, how is she magically supposed to be able to cope with her new reality?

I'm not saying that to criticize.

Those threads were inspired by my parent's stories of trying to help women in those exact situations (due to death or divorce) with their financial counseling ministry.

Like many topics in the Christian community, I think it's an important issue that people need to talk about -- and actively plan for whenever possible.
Oh, I got ya. You thread is really about you telling women to get financially capable. Not about you complaining society is trashing independent women. You're a bait-and-switcher poster! lol jk...
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
Oh, I got ya. You thread is really about you telling women to get financially capable. Not about you complaining society is trashing independent women. You're a bait-and-switcher poster! lol jk...
Go beyond that put your trust in god.The money thing is puny gentile thinking.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
Believe me, it IS an issue. Kauko just became (briefly) infamous here in the forum for harping on it so long.

https://christianchat.com/christian...ere-single-christian-girls-in-finland.200207/

48 pages long, so get ready for a long read. But you asked for it. :p

Basically he wants to find a meek, dependent girl who will worship him and never go out of his sight.
So you mean Kauko is an issue. Society trashing independent women is not.

You know, one red rock on a white sands beach is not a red rock problem. :sneaky:
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
So you mean Kauko is an issue. Society trashing independent women is not.

You know, one red rock on a white sands beach is not a red rock problem. :sneaky:
That's the crazy thing sometime it has to do with what one focuses on.What your saying about a red rock is true but people are crazy.The bible says in the last days all nations will go mad = crazy.o_O
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,725
9,656
113
So you mean Kauko is an issue. Society trashing independent women is not.

You know, one red rock on a white sands beach is not a red rock problem. :sneaky:
I have met many red rocks. What beach are you walking on?
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
The beach of secular ignorance under the guise of religion.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
That's the crazy thing sometime it has to do with what one focuses on.What your saying about a red rock is true but people are crazy.The bible says in the last days all nations will go mad = crazy.o_O
So true, it's about our focus.

We are to be hopeful and ready for Christ's return. When Christ was here, he said he didn't know when it was going to happen, and that only God does. We need to keep it that way. We know the 1st century christians thought it was going to happen any second. Two thousand years later... I personally don't think we should be making the same mistake the 1st christians were making... focusing on the "end times", or at least saying it is the "end times", unless you mean it's always the end times, like the day Christ went to heaven. What do you think?
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
Since our god be money in this case. i guess we all have to teach woman the Rich Dad poor dad doctrine.How to acquire assets will keeping our liabilities to a minimum.Lets start here:The main difference between assets and liabilities is that assets provide a future economic benefit, while liabilities present a future obligation.Your never go broke by making your self a prophet,,,Your become rich in faith the love of god.
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
So true, it's about our focus.

We are to be hopeful and ready for Christ's return. When Christ was here, he said he didn't know when it was going to happen, and that only God does. We need to keep it that way. We know the 1st century christians thought it was going to happen any second. Two thousand years later... I personally don't think we should be making the same mistake the 1st christians were making... focusing on the "end times", or at least saying it is the "end times", unless you mean it's always the end times, like the day Christ went to heaven. What do you think?
The trouble with me is i forget that i'm never alone,and i tend to try to make my rightness independent of gods.If one foundation is in pride we tend to make more doctrinal mistake.O,,,, quality over quantity as far as bible know.of course we have to start with repentence.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
I have met many red rocks. What beach are you walking on?
Did you call the police? lol

So you're saying a lot of peeps you know personally have told you they think women shouldn't be able to financially support themselves (financially independent)? Is that a white sands issue? Here in the work-a-day world that talk was in the black and white movies. lol
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,147
368
83
Since our god be money in this case. i guess we all have to teach woman the Rich Dad poor dad doctrine.How to acquire assets will keeping our liabilities to a minimum.Lets start here:The main difference between assets and liabilities is that assets provide a future economic benefit, while liabilities present a future obligation.Your never go broke by making your self a prophet,,,Your become rich in faith the love of god.
Rich dad poor dad's been on my to-read-list for 20 years. never read it. can you recommend the smallest most current, best read or video for that? especially if there's a good video on that. I read, but just assume see a mini documentary. thanks!
 
Aug 20, 2021
1,863
310
83
Rich dad poor dad's been on my to-read-list for 20 years. never read it. can you recommend the smallest most current, best read or video for that? especially if there's a good video on that. I read, but just assume see a mini documentary. thanks!
I'm not really even suppose to recommend videos because it's a violation of the second commandment.So is being on computer.However those videos are so abundant you could just typed it in on you tube.Simple doctrine financial education so you can see the difference between whats makes one rich and what puts one in debt.Very secular but could be applied to investing in god.