I give them eternal life, and they will never perish
as you have here, doesn't show anything.
I give them eternal life, and they will never perish
Never perish even if they quit hearing and following Christ?
I give them eternal life, and they will never perish
as you have here, doesn't show anything.
I give them eternal life, and they will never perish
Originally Posted by Atwood
Ye Olde Present Tense Canard, The PTC:
It has been claimed that the use of the present tense in Bible verses (which appear to assert security), destroys eternal security, as if the present tense were the only tense used in such contexts. On such a PTC perversion of God's promise, when scripture says "that whosoeverbelieves in Him should not perish," it may be claimed that the meaning is that whosoevercontinually believes and does not stop believing" does not perish, but if a Christian should slip up and stop believing some day, he is out of luck.
So if the Bible reports in some story: Joe eats pork chops, that would mean, Joe eats pork chops continually and never stops! So when James says "In many things we all stumble," the meaning would be that the Christian stumbles continually and never stops stumbling. This is perversion of the present tense.
But the Present Tense Canarder need give heed to the following in John 5:1 " "Whosoever believes that Jesus is the Christ is begotten of God: and whosoever loves him that begat loves [present tense] [him also that is begotten of him."
On the PTC then, John 5:1 implies eternal security; for it would mean that the Christian not only loves God and other Christians, but continually loves God and other Christians without stopping! Surely only a saved person does that.
On the "present tense canard," this verse would mean that the Christian continually loves and never stops loving; thus how could the Christian be lost?
One way to translate the present tense is with progressive, on-going action, if the context permits it. "Joe eats" would then be "Joe is eating." But the present tense does not imply "without stopping." The present tense in this example does not mean "Joe continually eats and never stops." Actually in the appropriate context, the present tense can mean an action going on "is eating." But the idea of whether or not or how soon it stops is not implied by the present tense. "in many things we all stumble" cannot mean that Christians continually sin without stopping, nor even "continually sin.
When the NT says, "believes," it can be translated "is believing."
For the assurance which follows applies to the a Christian in his present time. If at that present time he is believing, he is promised (stretching into the future forever) that he will not perish. Thus if you are right now believing, trusting in Christ (an action indeed going on), you have assurance of eternal life as a consequence.
But to further clench the conclusion, it should be noted that sometimes in an eternal security verse the present tense is not used.
as Philippians 1:6b states:
"He who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ. "
"He who began [past tense] a good work in you will [future tense] bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ. "
The beginning began at a point in time. Christians don't ooze into being Christians. Their beginning is called a new birth (John 3) when they are begotten by God. A birth, by its very nature, occurs at a point in time. The new birth is a birth to a new life which is eternal, eternal life; i.e., regeneration, as in John 3:16 to everlasting life.
2 Cor 5:17 "Wherefore if any man is in Christ, he is a new creature: the old things are passed away; behold, they are become new."
John 5:1, 4,18 calls the Christian "begotten of God,"
5:1 "Whosoever believes that Jesus is the Christ is begotten of God: and whosoever loves him that begat loves him also that is begotten of him."
As noted above, on the "present tense canard" this verse would mean that the Christian continually loves and never stops loving; thus how could the Christian be lost? If love is the fruit of the Spirit (Gal 5), then how could this man in whose being the Spirit continually brings forth love (without stopping) ever become unsaved?
But when the present tense is used for on-going action, the present tense itself does not indicate "without stopping" nor any particular continuation time.
Yes, the text says "will perform it" with no conditions added; the implied condition is that He began it (which cannot be undone). One does not begin a work conditionally; you begin it or you don't. The beginning is not a matter of condition. The condition question comes in the continuation; and that is affirmed here.
Because the present tense may be used where action is continuing does not prove it always means that; nor does the fact of continuing action imply how long. If a man is sinning (in many things we all stumble -- present tense, it does not imply that we Christians sin continually and certainly not "continually without stopping." When the present tense is used for a process in action, that says nothing about how long it lasts; and often "continuous" is a distortion of its meaning.
But there is no evidence that Christians ever stop trusting Christ to get them to Heaven, neither is it reasonable that once just for believing, a new nature has been given to Christians (they have been begotten by God in the past) to suppose that they could be unborn and lose that nature. Scripture never has any such hint. Instead it declares that the believer has eternal life.
sometimes in an eternal security verse the present tense is not used, but the past tense:
as Philippians 1:6b states:
"He who began a good work in you will bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ. "
"He who began [past tense] a good work in you will[future tense] bring it to completion at the day of Jesus Christ. "
----------------------
that ye stand fast in one spirit, with one soul striving for the faith of the gospel; and in nothing affrighted by the adversaries: which is for them an evident token of perdition, but of your salvation, and that from God; because to you it has been granted [past time] in the behalf of Christ, not only
to believe [present tense!] on him,
but also to suffer in his behalf:
< Philip 1
If present tense means to continue without stopping, then it has been granted [gift of God] to Christians to believe continually without stopping!
Prove it Seabass.
When Peter was denying the Lord Jesus, are you saying the Lord Jesus was not faithful to Peter? Did not the Lord Jesus know that Peter would deny Him and despite that, pray that Peter's faith would not fail? And was not the Lord's prayer efficacious?
as Christ sheep and God is faithful to them by not allowing them to be snatched out of His hand. One that quits, become unfaithful in his hearing and following no longer qualifies as one of "MY" sheep removing himself from God's hand.[/quote]Atwood said:Where is any qualifier, Seabass? The Lord Jesus makes an assertion about His sheep that they do hear Him and follow Him. If they are sheep, they hear and follow.
Wrong. The sheep are identified by hearing and following; hearing & following does not make them sheep.
Atwood said:The text says not such thing, it says that of the sheep: "I give them eternal life and they shall never perish!" It is a gift given to sheep.
For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves, not of works lest anyone should boast.
Repeating this does not help your position.Atwood said:Stop making things up Seabass. The condition of God continuing the work to completion is that He began it, nothing else.
He Who began a good work in you will bring it to completion.
Dear Seabass, turn away from the lies of the enemy. Eternal life is yours if only you will trust the Savior completely with your destiny. Take the knee now. Do your vocal cords work? For whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved!
God will actually only chasten hid own, if one is his. And we are the ones that cause our own demise, and bring our own punishments
As in when we were a child, went out on Halloween. Got lots of candy, and were told not to eat too much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and what do we do, not listen and get sick. Does God punish us for this? I know flesh people, parents do, and we learn abuse and do not learn to .listen
God says why should I punish you Jimmy, you got sick did you not? Johnny says yes. So in essence Johnny you punished yourself by not listening and thus doing correct? Johnny. yes
The Lord says now next time will you listen and do according to what I ( God say)
And thus we see a loving Father, not the misguided flesh that punishes and punishes over one already punished for getting sick from not listening, have already punished themselves right or wrong?
When will we learn, how long as Jesus said, must he be with you, to the disciples, stating it is your Faith in him, to God the Father that you are saved
Luke 18:42 And Jesus said unto him, Receive thy sight: thy faith hath saved thee.
Ephesians 2:8 For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
Any work that you think is required nullifies the gift. Think on that for a minute or two
And that does not mean one does not do any works, this is to reveal the motive behind any works one does and will either be rewarded for it or burned up. The motive is what we need to see not in others, more so in our own selves you think?
Never perish even if they quit hearing and following Christ?
Through the OT, God chastened His chosen, elect people the Israelites over and over when they turned their back on God again and again turning to idols. They ended upon being cut off (Rom 11:20ff), lost (Rom 10:1-3).
on the Philippian jailer, you did not read far enough. Notice the same hour of the night he was baptized. Also noticed that he did not rejoice until after baptism. Why the urgency to baptize if it is not required?
I cannot prove a verse that does not exist and no verse exists that says God will remain faithful and save those that become unfaithful to Him.
as Christ sheep and God is faithful to them by not allowing them to be snatched out of His hand. One that quits, become unfaithful in his hearing and following no longer qualifies as one of "MY" sheep removing himself from God's hand.
"I give them eternal life" the "them" refer only to those ones that hear and follow. So if one quits hearing and following he is no longer one of the 'them".
Dear SeaBass,
No ifs ands or buts,
I give them eternal life, and they will never perish
Do you realize that when you use the Save/Savior terms, you do not even mean that same thing by them that we do? When you say save/saves/saved/saving/salvation/Savior, you mean that the Lord Jesus gives you a chance to be saved, if you do this or that in addition to him giving you a chance at eternal life. In fact, you deny salvation, and you deny that He is your Savior; at best He is a factor in your obtaining eternal life or a partial-savior.
When we say save/saves/saved/saving/salvation/Savior we mean that the Lord Jesus has changed our nature permanently to child of God and secured our blessed destiny to be with Him in a permanent state of bliss. We mean that we are sinners and have to be saved. He is the Savior; we are His savee.

You have to remember that Sea Perch and his buddies promote a works based salvation and even thought they teach you can loose your salvation they themselves have walked perfect and upright before their god of works and have never lost their losable salvation!
Atwood, What do you think John 4:42, and I John 4:14 means?
The very world, every single human being was saved. (past tense).
What are you actually believing in, in the first place?
Atwood, bro.. what is this?
[SUP]8 [/SUP]Wherefore if thy hand or thy foot offend thee, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into everlasting fire.
[SUP]9 [/SUP]And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
Matthew 18

There were some 35 texts that Atwood listed that he thinks means faith alone, though none do. But as well, one text, James 2:24 refutes all of them is one swoop. They all have the Luther syndrome.
The text does NOT say "Will perform it unconditionally no matter what the Philippians do".
Again....those Philippians had become Christians IN THE PAST so God started to perform that good work IN THE PAST back when they became Christians.
1 Tim 4:16 "save thyself"
1 Tim 5:22 "keep thyself pure"
Saved, Saves, Salvation, Savior: Hopeful Terms for the Sinner
Attention Those Who Deny Eternal Security:
Do you realize that when you use the Save/Savior terms, you do not even mean that same thing by them that we do? When you say save/saves/saved/saving/salvation/Savior, you mean that the Lord Jesus gives you a chance to be saved, if you do this or that in addition to him giving you a chance at eternal life. In fact, you deny salvation, and you deny that He is your Savior; at best He is a factor in your obtaining eternal life or a partial-savior.
When we say save/saves/saved/saving/salvation/Savior we mean that the Lord Jesus has changed our nature permanently to child of God and secured our blessed destiny to be with Him in a permanent state of bliss. We mean that we are sinners and have to be saved. He is the Savior; we are His savee.
Can You Sing It!?
Jesus! I do now receive Him,
More than all in Him I find.
He hath granted me forgiveness,
I am His, and He is mine.
Refrain
Hallelujah! what a Savior!
Hallelujah! what a Friend!
Saving, helping, keeping, loving,
He is with me to the end.
Jesus! what a Friend for sinners!
Jesus! Lover of my soul;
Friends may fail me, foes assail me,
He, my Savior, makes me whole.
Jesus! what a Strength in weakness!
Let me hide myself in Him.
Tempted, tried, and sometimes failing,
He, my Strength, my victory wins.
Jesus! what a Help in sorrow!
While the billows over me roll,
Even when my heart is breaking,
He, my Comfort, helps my soul.
Jesus! what a Guide and Keeper!
While the tempest still is high,
Storms about me, night overtakes me,
He, my Pilot, hears my cry.